Suspended Sentences Issued in Case of Deceased French Streamer Raphaël Graven
Two content creators received suspended prison terms and fines following the 2025 death of a popular streamer during a live broadcast. While the court ruled on aggravated violence, the defendants were not charged with manslaughter due to the victim's underlying health conditions.
Key takeaways
- Safine Hamadi and Owen Cenazandotti received suspended sentences for aggravated violence against streamer Raphaël Graven.
- Manslaughter charges were avoided as medical reports cited the victim's fragile heart and poor health as the probable cause of death.
- The streaming platform Kick is currently under investigation by French authorities following the live-broadcasted fatality.
- Both convicted men are banned from the Kick platform for six months and must pay combined fines totaling €20,000.
Legal Outcome for Hamadi and Cenazandotti
A French court has convicted Safine Hamadi and Owen Cenazandotti of aggravated violence following the death of 46-year-old streamer Raphaël Graven. The victim, known online as Jean Pormanove, died in August 2025 in Contes, a village located north of Nice. The court sentenced Cenazandotti to a two-year suspended prison term and a €15,000 fine. Hamadi, who expressed remorse during the proceedings, received an 18-month suspended sentence and a €5,000 fine. Both individuals are prohibited from posting content on the streaming platform Kick for six months.
Why It Matters
The case highlights the legal complexities of consent and liability in the extreme stunt streaming industry. Although Graven was subjected to routine verbal humiliation and physical abuse for his audience of over one million followers, the prosecution did not pursue manslaughter charges. Medical evidence suggested Graven’s death likely resulted from a fragile heart and poor general health rather than direct trauma. Furthermore, the court acquitted the pair of abusing Graven's psychological frailty because the streamer had previously told police he consented to the stunts.
Key Facts
- Raphaël Graven died during an August 18, 2025, livestream that showed him lifeless on a mattress.
- The platform Kick remains under investigation by French authorities regarding its oversight of such content.
- Hamadi and Cenazandotti maintained that the humiliation and abuse seen on screen occurred with Graven's permission.
- The fatal broadcast has since been removed from the platform.
What Happens Next
While the criminal proceedings against the two creators have concluded, the regulatory status of Kick in France remains uncertain. A spokesperson for the platform told the New York Times that Kick was not a party to the trial and that the ruling applied exclusively to the individual creators involved. Government investigators continue to review the platform's role in hosting content that features physical violence and systematic humiliation.
Source: BBC — World
Related stories
Severe Typhoon Dolphin Disrupts Power and Travel in Okinawa Before Approaching China
Jorge Messi, Architect of Son's Football Legacy, Dies at 68
Spain Initiates Reciprocal Border Checks as Schengen Dispute with Italy Escalates
